General Information
Referee details
*
Name
Surname
E-mail
*
Manuscript Title
*
Detail Assessment
1. Relevance of topic
To CS audience’s interest, to the theme proposed in the call for papers
*
High
Medium
Low
Comments:
2. Quality of argumentation
Objectives clearness, methodology appropriateness, analysis and interpretation correctness, conclusions soundness
*
High
Medium
Low
Comments:
3. Quality of writing
Clearness and concision, issues of grammar and punctuation
*
High
Medium
Low
Comments:
4. Originality
New insights, impact of the article on its research field, usefulness of findings
*
High
Medium
Low
Comments:
5. References adequacy
Thoroughness of literature review, accuracy of references
*
High
Medium
Low
Comments:
6. Abstract
*
Please Select
Accept as is
Minor revision
Major revision
Comments
Linguistic deficiencies, it does not summarize properly the manuscript content, abstract not provided
Overall Assessment
Manuscript
*
Please Select
Accept as written with no need for any revisions
Accept with minor revisions
Accept with major revisions
Do not accept for publication
Additional comments or suggestions to be sent to the author(s)
Confidential comments to editor(s)
Manuscript file with comments
In addition to standard revision, reviewer is free to comment and suggest changes directly on the manuscript file
Submit
Submit
Should be Empty: